WhatsApp Group Members
Eight men who were members of WhatsApp text messaging group were arrested in October 2018 and are serving prison sentences of up to eight years for inciting religious discord and promoting terrorism. Five members of the group remain imprisoned.
Azamat Umbetaliyev, Beket Mynbasov, Samat Adilov, Zhuldyzbek Taurbekov, Zhasulan Iskakov, Nazim Abdrakhmanov, Ernar Samatov, and Bolatbek Nurgaliyev are practicing Muslims who resided in various regions of Kazakhstan. Prior to their arrests in October 2018, none of the men had a criminal history and many of them had never met each other in person.
In December 2013, Nurgaliyev created a WhatsApp group to share information and engage in discussions concerning Islam. His stated intention was to create a forum to discourage individuals from engaging in terrorist activities, which he opposed. Between 2013 and 2018, the group grew to 171 members and thousands of messages were exchanged.
All eight men were members of the WhatsApp group in October 2018, but the involvement of each varied. A significant portion of activity involved simply sharing articles by Islamic scholars. Some members posted articles and comments more frequently than others. One of the men, Abdrakhmanov, only ever sent one message to the group – a section of text that he copied and reposted from an earlier message. Another man, Adilov, only joined the group 12 days prior to his arrest and never presented his own opinions or analysis.
Kazakhstan’s National Security Committee (KNB) first obtained messages from the WhatsApp group as early as August 2018. In September 2018, the KNB commissioned an expert analysis of texts, which concluded the messages showed “signs of agitating of religious discord.” A second expert determined the messages propagated “religious-radical views.” A criminal case was opened on October 18, 2018 after the KNB received a written statement from an anonymous source who claimed participants in the group actively discussed “religious topics.”
On October 27 and 28, 2018, KNB officers arrested seven of the eight men either at their homes or at public locations near their residences. In the case of Umbetaliyev, officers lured him outside of his home under the pretense that they wished to discuss some religious matters with him. Umbetaliyev was then assaulted by a group of plainclothes officers who pushed him into one of the eight cars that the officers arrived in. Similarly, Nurgaliyev, was lured to a nearby market under the pretense of a potential business transaction. Once Nurgaliyev arrived at the market, masked men seized him. The eighth man, Adilov, was later arrested when he sought to testify to KNB officers that the WhatsApp group was only used for religious discussion.
On February 18, 2019, all eight men were charged under Article 174 of the Kazakh Criminal Code for inciting social, national, clan, racial or religious discord. The indictment claimed that because the WhatsApp group’s founder, Nurgaliyev, is a Salafi Muslim and because groups following similar ideology have conducted terrorist activities, the WhatsApp group therefore promoted terrorism. Four of the men, including Nurgaliyev, were also charged under Article 256 of the Criminal Code, which prohibits promoting terrorism.
The trial of the eight men officially began on March 12, 2019 and spanned for the next five months. Over the course of the trial, the prosecutor’s office sent four successive prosecutors to try the government’s case. The government presented no evidence that any members of the group advocated, encouraged, or condoned acts of terrorism. The only connection made between the petitioners and terrorism was the allegation that their denomination of Islam was Salafism.
On August 5, 2019, the court found seven of the defendants guilty of violating Article 174. Nurgaliyev, Samatov, and Mynbasov were also found guilty of violating Article 256. Abdrakhmanov, Adilov, Iskakov, and Umbetaliyev were sentenced to five and a half years’ imprisonment; Samatov and Mynbasov were sentenced to seven and a half years’ imprisonment; Nurgaliyev was sentenced to eight years imprisonment. The eighth defendant, Taurbekov, was found guilty of violating both Article 174 and 256 and sentenced to seven years in prison in January 2020, due to a health condition that postponed his trial.
As of January 2022, none of the other 162 members of the WhatsApp group have been arrested, indicted, or tried in relation to their membership in the group.
On December 6, 2021, Umbetaliyev was released from prison on probation, having served three years and one month of his five and a half year sentence. In January 2022, Taurbekov was released from prison on probation after paying a fine, having served three years and two months of his seven year sentence. In April 2022, Iskakov was released from prison on probation, having served three years and six months of his five and a half year sentence.
Freedom Now and the Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights filed a petition in December 2020 with the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention on behalf of the eight men. The Working Group issued an opinion in September 2021 finding their detention to be a violation of international law.
Related News Posts
Enforcing the Rule of Law
Opinion of the UN Working Group on Arbitrary DetentionSeptember 8, 2021
Petition to the UN Working Group on Arbitrary DetentionDecember 7, 2020
Donate Today and Help Free a Prisoner of Conscience
Can you imagine a doctor being imprisoned just for treating a patient, or a journalist detained simply for publishing an article critical of his government?